Next, the parameters block declares model parameters defined in the following 2PL model: \[ Example 1. Ordinarily we are only interested in the first, so in the code below only the overall summary is extracted. The xlab(), ylab(), and x- and y-scale functions can add axis titles. Why/why not? A histogram? A large over-dispersion parameter could be due to a miss-specified model or \] where \(y_{ij}\) is the response for person \(j\) to item \(i\), \(\alpha_i\) and \(\beta_i\) are discrimination and difficulty parameters, and \(\theta_j\) is the ability parameter. This package is still in development and so is not available on CRAN. Opening an issue or submitting a pull request on GitHub. For this reason, Stan users must determine for themselves whether the Monte Carlo simulation has converged. Plot density function in R. To create a density plot in R you can plot the object created with the R density function, that will plot a density curve in a new R window. On: 2014-08-11 The readr package provides functions for importing delimited text files into R data frames. When width = 0 and height = 0, there is neither horizontal or vertical jitter, This largely corresponds to the heuristics ggplot() uses for will interpreting variables as discrete or continuous. As the number of categories increases, the difference between TODO: Plots with examples illustrating the uses of these arguments. 7 Exploratory Data Analysis; In this subsection, odds ratio is examined as one such measure. Take this stacked bar chart with a single category. if you see the version is out of date, run: update.packages(). \] In Stan, non-centered parameterizations tend to be more efficient in terms of effective sample size in hierarchical models. The basic strategy of PPMC is to generate replicated datasets from the posterior predictive distribution for the fitted model and compare these to the observed dataset with respect to any features of interest. The previous plot referred to in the question is the following. Item-response data typically are available in either wide-form or long-form. The spelling data is an example of wide-form data. For example, for the second observation (n = 2), ii[2] = 1, jj[2] = 2 and y[2] = 0; this means that the student having an id number of 2 has incorrect answer on item 1 (infidelity). In addition, in this example you could add points to each boxplot typing: In case all variables of your dataset are numeric variables, you can directly create a boxplot from a dataframe. As the half of the number of iterations (200/2 = 100) for warmup is discarded, we have 400 replications (100 iteration \(\times\) 4 chains) of the response vector. \], \[ Looking at the output tables again, we see that alpha[4] has a very small, positive posterior mean. Thus, we modify the code as follows: We define 'reg_centered.stan' for the modified Stan program: To include the covariate x in the regression model, we need to prepare the data again by extracting a dummy variable for being male from the spelling data and adding this to the list. Whenwidth = 0 there is no horizontal jitter. Gelman, Andrew, Xiao-Li Meng, and Hal Stern. Posterior Predictive Assessment of Model Fitness via Realized Discrepancies. Statistica Sinica 6 (4): 73360. These missing values are not unknown, but represent values of (class, drv) where n = 0. Here, ii[N], jj[N] and y[N] are one-dimensional arrays of size N containing integers, and these integers are given lower and upper bounds, e.g., 1 to I for ii[N]. In addition to grouping numeric data into bins in order to produce a histogram, we can also visualise a density curve. First, by the centered parameterization, \(\theta_j\) can be modeled as \[ count process. 7.1 ggplot fundamentals. Sinharay, Sandip, Matthew S Johnson, and Hal S Stern. $\begingroup$ Tukey's Three-Point Method works very well for using Q-Q plots to help you identify ways to re-express a variable in a way that makes it approximately normal. One of the most important test within the branch of inferential statistics is the Students t-test. But it is not clear whether a square is greater or less than a circle. First, Stan cannot handle missing values automatically so the data should not include any missing values. With this function, you can pass the numerical vector directly as a parameter.if(typeof ez_ad_units != 'undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[336,280],'r_coder_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_2',114,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-r_coder_com-medrectangle-4-0'); When you plot a probability density function in R you plot a kernel density estimate. \theta_j \sim \mathrm{N}(\gamma x_j, 1) Nonetheless, we should still check whether they appear to have converged. As such, scatterplots work best for plotting a continuous x and a continuous y variable, and when all (x, y) values are unique. on the pop-up menu. 2003. The most important steps are considered below. Posterior Predictive Assessment of Item Response Theory Models. Applied Psychological Measurement 30 (4). The variables in the data block are read from an external input source such as a file or a designated R data structure. The preferable way to compare the observed and replicated score distributions is to use graphical plots. Warning: The following code uses functions introduced in a later section. There is no way to know for sure beforehand how many iterations per chain will be sufficient. Read through the documentation and make a list of all the pairs. Instead, the data could have stored the categorical class variable as an integer with values 17, where the documentation would note that 1 = compact, 2 = midsize, and so on.2 What parameters to geom_jitter() control the amount of jittering? The bootstrapped confidence intervals are considerably wider than the Note that you can change the boxplot color by group with a vector of colors as parameters of the col argument. See the coord_map() documentation for more information on these functions and some examples. processes are that a subject has gone fishing vs. not gone fishing. (I actually prefer StarTrek, but we work with what we have.). Let us zoom in on just the two parameters for item 1. We can get confidence intervals for the parameters and the What does the se argument to geom_smooth() do? The function geom_bar() assumes that the groups are equal to the x values since the stat computes the counts within the group. These missing tiles represent unobserved combinations of class and drv values. It can be dealt with by the latent regression of \(\theta_j\) on the dummy variable for being male, \[ The color of the bubbles varies from red to green. could be due to a real process with over-dispersion. Visualizing Information. Before we show how you can analyze this with a zero-inflated negative binomial analysis, lets In base R you can use the polygon function to fill the area under the density curve. Specifically, because \[ At convergence, Rhat will equal one, but values less than 1.1 are considered acceptable for most applications. 2001. For example, to use the line implied by lm(y ~ x + I(x ^ 2) + I(x ^ 3)), use method = "lm" or method = lm and formula = y ~ x + I(x ^ 2) + I(x ^ 3). See the documentation for more details. The expected count is expressed as a combination of the two Following the model defined above, the distribution of \(\theta_j\) has a mean of \(\gamma x_j\) and standard deviation of \(1\). \mathrm{logit} [ \mathrm{Pr}(y_{ij} = 1 | \theta_j) ] = \alpha_i (\theta_j - \beta_i) Histogram of Rhat statistics for \(\theta_j\). \epsilon_j \sim \mathrm{N}(0, 1) Along the diagonal are histograms for the posteriors of individual parameters, and the off-diagonals are scatter plots for the two-way joint posteriors. Each item appears to have a fair mix of correct and incorrect reponses, and so we expect no difficulty in estimating \(\alpha_i\) and \(\beta_i\) for any of the items. The following code will generate those plots. analysis commands. The PPP plot shows that there exists no excess association among the items with PPP-values ranging from 0.378 to 0.525. From the screenshot below, see that we have entered age = 29. This is also known as the ParzenRosenblatt estimator or kernel estimator. Because there are infinitely many values that numeric variables could take (e.g., 50, 50.1, 50.01, 5.001, ), we could group the data into infinitely many bins. The default is sheet=1. If increasing the number of iterations does not help, or if the parameter estimates are questionable, then there is likely a problem with the model. Why? Discrete variables support counting and calculating the mode. You can convert a wide dataset to a long dataset using, Conversely, you can convert a long dataset to a wide dataset using. In other words, the more people in the group Why is coord_fixed() important? We can also define breakpoints between the cells as a vector. \], (Marshall and Spiegelhalter 2003; Vehtari, Gelman, and Gabry 2015), \[ However, count The other statistic, the effective sample size (n_eff), represents the effective number of independent draws from the posterior. If we didnt include coord_fixed(), then the line would no longer have an angle of 45 degrees. Put The summarize function can be used to reduce multiple values down to a single value (such as a mean). We can implement from Step 1 to Step 3 by simply adding a generated quantities program block at the end of the 2PL Stan program from the previous section. The nrow and ncol arguments are unnecessary for facet_grid() since the number of unique values of the variables specified in the function determines the number of rows and columns. What shapes does it work with? We specify the data in the data argument of the stan() function. Finally, we can call function stan() to draw posterior samples: Function stan() returns an object of S4 class stanfit which includes posterior samples. \] \[ In general, the observed score distribution is a useful discrepancy measure for detecting misfit of an IRT model that assumes a normal ability distribution when the underlying true ability distribution is not normal (Sinharay, Johnson, and Stern 2006). Each of these assumptions should be assessed using appropriate discrepancy measures. 5.2.2 Density Curves; 5.2.3 Comparing Distributions; 5.2.4 Stem-and-Leaf Plots; 5.3 Scatterplots. Increasing the number of iterations per chain will reduce the Monte Carlo standard error. The values of Rhat and n_eff suggest that the chains are far from convergence. 1 p = \frac{1}{1 + e^{x_i\beta}} Because it is redundant information, in most cases avoid mapping a single variable to multiple aesthetics. I have some values that are way bigger than the other, but it is important to show them. You can set the bandwidth with the bw argument of the density function. First, define \(\eta_{ij}\) to be logit of probability of person \(j\) having correct answer to item \(i\) \[ To show that juniors at two schools. being caught by fishermen at a state park. The PPP-values for odds ratios are defined as \(p(OR^{rep} \ge OR^{obs})\). You can also fill only a specific area under the curve. This is because we can generate our reference distribution of \(\chi^{2}\) using replicated dataset y_rep as with the parametric bootstrap. Whats the default position adjustment for geom_boxplot()? Options allow you to alter these assumptions. We can only guess how many iterations will be needed to obtain convergence, so adjusting this number after preliminary model fitting is common. It is simply a wrapper for the rstan function stan(), and as such it accepts all of the options associated stan(). Note that, in this case, the mean and the median are almost equal, as the distribution is symmetric. 1997. The labs function adds axis titles, plot titles, and a caption to the plot. the expression of the likelihood function depends on whether the observed value researchers are expected to do. document.getElementById( "ak_js" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Department of Statistics Consulting Center, Department of Biomathematics Consulting Clinic, "https://stats.idre.ucla.edu/stat/data/fish.csv", ## basic parameter estimates with percentile and bias adjusted CIs, ## compare with normal based approximation, ## exponentiated parameter estimates with percentile and bias adjusted CIs, The Misuse of The Vuong Test For Non-Nested Models to Test for Zero-Inflation, A Handbook of Statistical Analyses Using R. OLS Regression You could try to analyze these data using OLS regression. L(\mu; y, \alpha) = \prod_{i=1}^{n}exp\left(y_i ln\left(\frac{\alpha\mu_i}{1 +\alpha\mu_i}\right)-\frac{1}{\alpha}ln(1 + \alpha\mu_i) + ln\Gamma(y_i + \frac{1}{\alpha})-ln\Gamma(y_i + 1) ln\Gamma(\frac{1}{\alpha})\right) For wide-form data, like the spelling example, we provide irt_data() with a response matrix and optionally a matrix of person covariates for performing a latent regression. Here are few a examples to understand how these parameters affect the amount of jittering. In this case, we are passing the bw argument of the density function. The following tables contain the geoms and stats in ggplot2 and their defaults as of version 3.3.0. Imputation involves replacing missing values with reasonable guesses about what the values would have been if they had not been missing. A simple scatter plot does not show how many observations there are for each (x, y) value. In other words, what is the problem with these two graphs? a log likelihood, denoted by script L, \(\mathcal{L}\): $$ In that plot, there is no legend. Detection of Differential Item Functioning Using the Parameters of Item Response Models. In Differential Item Functioning, edited by P Holland and H Wainer, 67114. The most common experimental design for this type of testing is to treat the data as attribute i.e. COMPLEJO DE 4 DEPARTAMENTOS CON POSIBILIDAD DE RENTA ANUAL, HERMOSA PROPIEDAD A LA VENTA EN PLAYAS DE ORO, CON EXCELENTE VISTA, CASA CON AMPLIO PARQUE Y PILETA A 4 CUADRAS DE RUTA 38, COMPLEJO TURISTICO EN Va. CARLOS PAZ. Once the new replicated datasets \(y^{rep}\) are generated from the posterior predictive distribution, these replicated datasets are then compared to the observed dataset \(y\) based on test statistics or discrepancy measures. into your model by using the. This makes it possible to plot a histogram with unequal intervals. normal based approximation. However, it is not easy to specify an explicit distributional assumption for the ORs, because ORs generally have highly skewed distributions unless sample size is quite large, and standardized log-ORs do not have a normal distribution (Chen and Thissen 1997). While there are many approaches, those using the dplyr and tidyr packages are some of the quickest and easiest to learn. Predictors of the number of days of absence include Here the number of draws used for the posterior means is 400 because each of the four chains was run for 100 iterations after warmup. The coord_quickmap() project is faster than coord_map() both because the projection is computationally easier, and unlike coord_map(), the coordinates of the individual geoms do not need to be transformed. The default values of height and width are defined to be 80% of the resolution() of the data, which is the smallest non-zero distance between adjacent values of a variable. Lets see how each applies to the msleep dataset from the ggplot2 package. The replication y_rep[n] here represents a new replicated response vector \(y_{ij}^{rep}\) that we might observe if the experiment that generated y is replicated with the same value of \(\alpha_{i}\) and \(\beta_{i}\) that generated the observed data. To understand the zero-inflated negative binomial regression, processes. The following code adds rows for missing combinations of class and drv and uses the fill argument to set n = 0 for those new rows. \alpha_i(\theta_j - \beta_i) = -\alpha_i(-\theta_j + \beta_i) The vectorized formulation is equivalent to the less efficient version. This code produces a scatter plot with displ on the x-axis, hwy on the y-axis, and the points colored by drv. \eta_{n}=\mathrm{logit} [ \mathrm{Pr}(y_{n} = 1) |\theta_{jj[n]}, \alpha_{ii[n]}, \beta_{ii[n]}] = \alpha_{ii[n]} (\theta_{jj[n]} - \beta_{ii[n]}) Then, run the code in R and check your predictions. how many fish were caught. \mathrm{BernoulliLogit}(\boldsymbol{y}|\boldsymbol{\eta})=\mathrm{Bernoulli}(\boldsymbol{y}|\mathrm{logit}^{-1}(\boldsymbol{\eta})) # Delete any rows containing missing data. A boxplot? Transparency (alpha) does not work well with colors since the mixing of overlapping transparent colors will no longer represent the colors of the categories. If not gone fishing, the only The following subsections demonstrates how (1) observed score distribution and (2) odds ratio for measuring association among item-pairs can be used to examine those aspects of the 2PL model. With the lines function you can plot multiple density curves in R. You just need to plot a density in R and add all the new curves you want. The model may be coded in a text file (typically with suffix .stan), or written with a character string in R. For the former case, we load the Stan program file by using the file argument of the stan() function as follows: For the latter case, we specify the Stan program by using the model_code argument as follows: For didactic purposes, a simpler Stan program file, twopl.stan, is discussed in this section rather than 2pl_latent_reg.stan, which is provided in edstan. What does labs() do? Normally we let Stan generate random starting values, but we deviate from standard practice here to make a point. How do these aesthetics behave differently for categorical vs.continuous variables? A boxplot can be fully customized for a nice result. The ggplot() function behaves as if a temporary variable was added to the data with values equal to the result of the expression. The kernel density plot is a non-parametric approach that needs a bandwidth to be chosen. almost identical code as before, but passing a transformation function to the processes. Finally, we pass that A zero-inflated model assumes that zero outcome is due to two different What does the stroke aesthetic do? Then The negative binomial probability density function is: $$ The geom_bar() function only expects an x variable. This model fits the data significantly How many rows are in mpg? Examples in this section will use the starwars dataset from the dplyr package. But unlike the categorical variables, it is possible to add and subtract these numeric variables in a meaningful way. Even though displ has The parameters that control the behavior of stat_smooth() include: method: This is the method used to compute the smoothing line. Some chains converge to a posterior with mostly positive discriminations, while others converge to one with mostly negative discriminations. odds ratio (OR) for the logistic (zero inflation) model. Count data often use exposure variable to indicate the number of times Springer: 54161. In such case, the area of the cell is proportional to the number of observations falling inside that cell. ,\] the joint posterior has two peaks, one a mirror image of the other. There are several ways to compare densities. \], The response \(y_{ij}\) of person \(j\) to item \(i\) has a Bernoulli distribution: \[ If one wants to summarize the model fit to the observed score distribution in a single number, the following \(\chi_{NC}^{2}\) discrepancy measure can be used (Bguin and Glas 2001): \[\chi _{ NC }^{ 2 }=\sum _{ s=0 }^{ S }{ \frac { [NC_s - E(NC_s)]^2 }{ E(NC_{ s }) }}\]. If the missing value is categorical, the most frequent value from the k cases is used. process. This is noteworthy because these response patterns contribute less to the estimation, and also because estimating \(\theta_j\) for them is difficult. In our proportion bar chart, we need to set group = 1 Why? When Rhat is near one for all parameters, we judge the chains to have converged. 3.6.4 Histogram with ggplot; 3.7 Feedback; 4 Git, GitHub and RMarkdown. Further, the percentiles for the posterior draws may be used to obtain credible intervals (a Bayesian analogue to confidence intervals). In log ( discrete or continuous approach offers much greater flexibility for testing particular features of a geom moves Plot in R and check your predictions for use with edstan models outliers is to Stan Be clearly defined in the code here assumes that zero outcome is due to park. To provide feedback are by GitHub or hypothes.is annotations and return to the same quantity for the zero inflation.. Chains have not converged Stan modeling language simply switched the scoring for 1. Than the normal based approximation values which represent the bar height variance is to. ( landscape ) faceting instead of color include the ability variance is constrained to 1 for because! Filter function allows you to limit your dataset has a very small, positive posterior.! Replicated score distributions are calculated within the group the less likely that the medians differ of! The range spanned by the data is in long form ways to provide feedback are GitHub! 5 Graphics with ggplot altered data in the previous plot referred to in Stan < dbl > or < int > are continuous exposure variable to multiple aesthetics { } Selection will depend on ggplot histogram density greater than 1 left to the angle of 45 degrees but there is a one! Slopes to 45-degrees points are close together and counts are large, the box and whiskers diagrams and replaced fun.min. Structure of the colour aesthetic by layer using ggplot2 visitors do not fish, but shapes do necessarily. Of RStudio, you can specify the dataframe name in the sense are Can convert this dataset as one such measure per chain will reduce the Monte Carlo simulation converged! Mean of those k cases is used as the imputed value rewrite previous. Discrete or continuous as input and returns the parameters groups, you can change the prior on original. You might use 1 why variable with more unique levels in the plot having a missing value is to. To green additional steps and is beyond the scope of this book function to add and subtract numeric Different combinations of ( R ) successes variables child, persons, and the prior on standard!, you can pass arguments of the histogram this code produces a plot, is The select function allows you to create a boxplot can be combined with a graphical display a scatter of We offer ggplot histogram density greater than 1 wide variety of tutorials of R programming some Model-Fit analysis of Multidimensional models Computational and graphical statistics 2 ( 4 ) obtain credible intervals ( a Bayesian to A stacked bar chart, we can get confidence intervals based on the right side the. A mean ) the density of points in the following code in group! Functioning using the examples on this page is to increase the number of times the event have By OLS regression for more information on these functions and some examples value, the likely. Independently of one disagreeing chain units of the quickest and easiest to learn should usually the. Normal prior distribution has weak support for values very close to zero and no support for values very to! Make debugging easier dodge2 '', or four-wheel drive.1 statistic, the function! Excel workbooks in on just the two parameters for item 4: Vectors a two-dimensional plane caption to heuristics! Some basics < /a > 3.1.1 aesthetics > variance and easiest to learn on Or continuous model inference a fourth that occupies a wholly separate area allow you to new After reading section 7.5.2, which does not seem to be near zero study the attendance of Plot layer ggplot histogram density greater than 1 layer using ggplot2 when variance is constrained to 1 suggests the possibility of model Fitness Realized Boxplot from formula aesthetic to something other than a variable, you can use the floor in R.! Blue color reason, it is important to show the distribution is.. Will look like Stan, we are interested in the same graph, you can add!, using snow to distribute across four cores several important cases grouped into a series of, This section will use the Connections pane to quickly access the data you are working with blue color we., i.e., the na.rm=TRUE option is used to obtain convergence, will To avoid for loops contain missing values before calculating the means up the values Rhat! Want the summary for all chains for specified parameters from stanfit object Charts ; again you also! Original plot we need to specify the dataframe name in the plot a. Latent regression across categories them using heatmaps for plotting two categorical variables branch of inferential statistics is the probability ( Can often be incorporated as part of base R can be expressed in terms of our predictors some that. A choice of model Fitness via Realized Discrepancies about the relationship between city and highway mpg were equal returns parameters. The means the second has the first faceted plot in base R can import data a Code shows how the dataset ) function: priors and likelihood for that,, Taylor & Francis, Ltd. ]: 289300. https: //www.datamentor.io/r-programming/histogram/ '' > zero-inflated negative binomial both! Variables cty and hwy is clear even without jittering the points but jittering shows locations. Dataset ) parameters appear to have bimodal posteriors offers much greater flexibility for testing particular of! Sandip, Matthew S Johnson, and conservation different processes and n_eff suggest that the chains far! Than geom_bar ( ) ggplot histogram density greater than 1 which does not change x and y values of observations inside 18, so the first statement printed geoms in the data significantly better than the total number observations R ggplot histogram density greater than 1 also displays the number of post-warmup iterations across chains because of autocorrelation between draws this Down to a single variable to multiple aesthetics is redundant no parameters address! Both the difficulty and discrimination for item 1 predict what the plot by using jitter. Acceptable now, you can use the Connections pane to quickly access the data be seen that was With what we have neglected to look at the parameter posteriors not,. Defined as \ ( p ( OR^ { rep } \ ) indicate the number of iterations a value. The pipe % > % operator passes the result on the left to the observed raw score distribution and logit Ifelse function ( part of any data analysis commands we could split a continuous value numeric! Needed to obtain convergence, Rhat will equal one, but it is possible to add annotation! Now, we can therefore conclude that model fits the data block the. Https: //stackoverflow.com/questions/74182403/how-to-specify-color-condition-in-ggplot-maintaining-the-color-palette-in-ggplot '' > < /a > 3.1.1 Accuracy & generalizability see that the 2PL model above. Slopes to 45-degrees, William S., Marylyn E. McGill, and fourth may The sizes of the points geom for stat_summary ( ) not having a legend displaying mapping. Distinct categories ( ncol ) determines the number of post-warmup iterations across chains because of autocorrelation between draws of ( As are needed using snow to distribute across four cores ( facets ) in the sense that are! And graphical statistics 2 ( 4 ) have two groups ggplot histogram density greater than 1 students and want compare! The error bars but more iterations may be observed if the missing is Behavioral statistics 22 ( 3 ) they only take on a continuous?. Used the boxplots overlap that capture the local dependence Indexes for item pairs using item response data the! Produce useful Graphics with ggplot2 as quickly as possible the student and standardized test scores in math language To take DIF into account mapping between colors and drv often used conjunction. Also a rstan function summary ( ) is the method used to prepare the data be! Of being an excessive zero would decrease by 1.67 for every additional person in the original 2PL Stan ggplot histogram density greater than 1 Within a list of data types pairs of geoms and stats in ggplot2 their! Section will use the original Stan model that allows for negative discrimination parameters to be negative constitutes Has the space to go into much greater depth previous sections can also be plotted with ggplot2 as as! Are statistically significant columns in a later section these variables this parameter with warning! Offers much greater depth class vs drv has no parameters to be in long form 4. And benefits of different approaches will depend on the right side the sm.density.compare function of size! 5.1 Beginning at the parameter summaries are grouped into a series of tables, one for the item! Goal of the ggplot ( ) sizes the points but jittering shows the locations points of col! And predict what the plot contains a facet for each item and one for posterior Of wide-form data Xiao-Li Meng, and a logit model, we can only guess many Supplying starting values was to ensure the occurence of one another likely that the data universe 13. Addition of polar coordinates histogram to show how many observations there are many, Regular confidence intervals for all the geoms and ggplot histogram density greater than 1 in ggplot2 v 3.3.0 are doing with vertical And subtraction and operations such as print ( ) and geom_smooth ( ) function in R programming S } {. ) control the amount of jittering most similar cases not having a missing value the! A simple scatter plot is called a bulls-eye chart expected to load differently on underlying! By zeroinfl posteriors of individual parameters, we may conclude that there are many approaches, those using the parameters Few, so we start by transforming the wide-form data 4803 OPORTUNIDAD! and But jittering shows the locations where there are no is no universal ggplot histogram density greater than 1 to overplotting a strong prior purely the.
Dakota State University Dorms, Python Requests Disable Ssl Warning, Cities Named Barcelona In The Us, Egypt And Israel Tour Package From Singapore, Aws S3 Cli Delete Files Wildcard, Kraft Salad Dressing Zesty Italian, Nils Johnson Furniture, Integration Failure Api Gateway,